Dear ____,
Why is it so difficult for us to actually communicate and talk? That seems like one of the most important aspects and foundations of a relationship. And yet when I open my mouth to say anything relationship-related, the iron curtain falls down around me on all sides. Crickets.
I know this can’t really be a breakup letter because we aren’t even really together. From the times I’ve tried to piece this all together from our snippets of conversation, here is what I have gathered. Yes, we are dating, and yes, it is actual dating, not “casual dating,” whatever that means. We are not exclusive and can date other people without it being considered cheating. We see each other almost every day. We go out together, spend weekends together, go boxing together. You don’t really want to help me with life stuff though. Your ideal scenario would be for what we have going on now (umm, what is that exactly again?) to last for as long as possible until I am ready to have children at which point I should find someone else. This has been going on more or less for 7 months. You remind me subtly at intervals that you weren’t interested in me at the outset. In fact, your first impression of me was that I was a “corporate bitch.” Then we went away on a trip with our friends, and you felt uncomfortable because you thought I was interested in you…and you weren’t interested in me. Great – thank you for that narrative. I feel really wanted.
When I need you, you don’t respond. You are typically sleeping. By my calculations, you sleep 12-15 hours a day and play video games during 25% of your waking hours. With the remainder of your time, we are usually eating or drinking (usually both), or you are working or having alone time.
I accepted all of these things because I truly love spending time with you. I haven’t wanted to be with anyone this much in a long time. You bring out my inner child, my sense of inspiration, and remind me how silly and yet poetic the world can be. You taught me how to set achievable goals and to detach from material possessions. You helped me relax and assume a slower pace of life. From you, I learned that you can basically learn how to do anything on YouTube, including being a near-Michelin starred chef. Who knew the tiny kernel in garlic was bitter and had to be removed? Who else takes time to dry and de-vein each individual shrimp piece by piece? Who else can go to Atlantic City and win $900 playing poker using skill instead of luck? Who else quits his job and doesn’t look back and lives in such a carefree manner? Who else comes to my dinner party and cooks an amazing meal for everyone and then subsequently gets so wasted that he takes off his clothing and starts doing and saying crazy things? You are insane, but you make (made?) me happy.
There are so many things I love, admire, and appreciate about you. However, there are things I really need to be in a happy and healthy relationship too, and I am not getting them. There are some basic things like a hello message in the morning or good night, something to let me know you’re there and thinking about me. I also wonder why it’s so hard for you to say nice things to me. To this day, I’ve never heard you say, “you’re pretty” or “you’re beautiful.” There was that one time you texted me, “That dress is A+++++,” while I was sitting next to you. There was another time you pointed to a dress I had worn the night before and was crumpled up on the table and said, “That dress looked nice on you.” Yesterday, you helped me take the boxes of books down from my closet, and as we assembled them to take them to Goodwill, you insulted every single one and triumphantly indicated that most other people would have been complimenting me on how well-read I was. Wow, good job. You are more of an asshole than other people. Am I supposed to be adoring you for that?
I am upset. I was falling in love. Then I realized you were spending hours a day on online dating sites (in the meantime, not responding to my texts). You even checked OKCupid once while I was sleeping in your bed! I eventually brought it up with you, and you said there was an easy solution and that you would just stop checking these sites. It was very unceremonious, and few words were exchanged. What about my feelings? Anyway, I shed some tears over that. There was another time I cried quite a bit wondering why it was so hard for you to just say one nice thing to me, something to make me feel amazing. Something genuine, heartfelt, and loving.
We drink too much. I had stopped drinking, and with you, I have started binge-drinking all the time. Some nights, we go out and drink at least 15 drinks each! That is just not healthy. I told you no more shots, and you continue to get us shots. I don’t have a life that lets me live that way. No more “One time, Grace. Just one time.” I’m not amused anymore.
You got me sick with some horrific virus recently, but where are you? You haven’t even checked in on me. I have people who barely know me asking me if I’m feeling better. Where are you?
I can’t even bring these things up with you! That is the worst part. We are great as friends, and I guess we will never be in a relationship.
I know you don’t want kids, but when I asked the hypothetical question about what you would do if I accidentally got pregnant, you said you would use your other passport to flee and leave the country. I said I wouldn’t make you take any responsibility, and you said you would just leave anyway. And if your future son showed up at your doorstep 30 years later, you said you would say sorry, I can’t have a relationship with you. I truly think you are a good-hearted person, so I am really confused about how cold you can be. I know you care about people and that you’re empathetic. I see you cheering up your friends. But when it comes to me, sometimes it is just radio silence. Or maybe I am refusing to see the real you somehow. Maybe you are a bad person, and I am just too blind to see it
I can’t really do it anymore. My patience has worn thin. Yesterday, you said that if you put me on a pedestal, I wouldn’t like it. By that, I think you mean that you think you need to be somewhat mean to me to get me to stick around. Maybe that’s true to some extent. It’s true that I don’t need someone who is going to bend to my will at every moment, and it is just not attractive when someone is overly submissive. No, I don’t need to be on a pedestal, but I deserved to be loved and adored for the person I am. I am tired of your implications that I am not pretty enough, thin enough, or whatever.
Fun times are sufficient for friends. I actually think we could be amazing lifelong friends. I just feel so frustrated by where things stand with us romantically. You’ve taught me patience, and I’ve broken the chain of being in highly co-dependent relationships, so I thank you for helping me see things differently. You have provided me support in some ways, and your presence has helped me make some really important changes in my life. It has also made me stronger and more balanced when facing my day-to-day responsibilities. I’ve probably consumed an extra 1K calories/day in food and 1K calories/day in alcohol with you, but it was needed – I needed to lighten up about my diet and grinding myself into the ground with all my rules of paleo, Atkins, calorie-counting, and Whole30 diets. I feel like a more complete person.
I guess I want more…but I only want more with someone who wants more and can actually be good to me and nice to me. I don’t want to be in a committed relationship with someone who is always marching to the beat of his own drum and might just leave at any moment. I need someone I can rely on.
You just called me back finally. I just got done Skyping with you. One of your comments was that you appreciated it when I wrote you earlier today and said I would stop texting you. Wow. Yes, I do understand and appreciate that you don’t like texting. Today is not the day for sharing that comment with me. I am super sick and have no voice. Where have you been?!
I think it’s time to close this chapter. I’m happy for the times we’ve had, and I strangely think we will seamlessly transition into friendship. We’re not good as a couple, but we are amazing as friends. Let’s do that and be friends forever. I still love you.
OK, let me not be contained for a moment and also say that I think you are an insanely selfish asshole manchild and at this moment, I also completely despise you. I cannot believe I emotionally invested in you as much as I did. I should have spent the time working on myself rather than trying to bend to you and become the woman you wanted me to be.
I would never send you this letter because I know it’s just too many words. You wouldn’t be able to read it. Screw you for all the ways in which you have made me feel insignificant and like I don’t even matter.
I’ve said my piece. I know we can get past this. Let’s just rip off the band-aid.
The Cat Lady